Drawdown study · John Collins · 22 Nov 2026

A depression within a bull.

The semiconductor sell-off began on 22 June. The business kept reporting through it. Put the two records on the same clock.

The October headline aged in one direction.

In July, SMH had lost 24.6% from 22 June while SPY was down roughly 2%. We called that a bear market inside a bull. By Friday, 20 November, SOXX had lost 43.6% of its June net asset value. The S&P 500 price index had fallen 7.5% over those same dates. The damage reached the broad market. It was still concentrated in semiconductors.

Meanwhile, the latest quarterly data-center revenue NVIDIA had reported rose from $75.2bn in June to $89.0bn in August and $107.6bn in November. Nearly as far up as the sector’s equity went down. That is what “depression within a bull” describes here. The industrial expansion and the equity drawdown coexisted.

The original October article · iShares SOXX · S&P 500 series · 20 Nov broad-market close · NVIDIA Q1 FY27 · NVIDIA Q2 FY27 · NVIDIA Q3 FY27

Market record

Inside the semiconductor drawdown

22 Jun – 20 Nov 2026
−43.6%
SOXX from its June high$123.23 net asset value · 20 Nov 2026
0%−20%−40%−50%JunJulAugSepOctNovJuly lowOctober rebound

Two stocks lost nearly 48%. What did the buyer get?

On 19 December 2000, a Cisco share cost $41.75. The previous four quarters had earned $0.41 a share. On 20 November 2026, $125.53 bought a share of NVIDIA with $9.31 of trailing earnings. Same GAAP basis. Roughly the same drawdown. A dollar of profit cost $102 in one case and under $14 in the other.

There is room for a serious bearish argument here. A buyer can question margins, customer concentration, the life of a rack or how much of a cloud contract survives refinancing. Each objection puts a different number at risk. Invoking dot-com without naming that number skips the investment question.

Valuation experiment · NVIDIA / Cisco

How much profit has to disappear?

Hold NVIDIA at its 20 November close of $125.53. Cut its trailing earnings and see what a dollar of the remaining profit would cost.

13.5×$9.31 trailing GAAP diluted EPS at $125.53 per share

Cisco on 19 Dec 2000: $41.75 ÷ $0.41 trailing diluted GAAP EPS = 101.8×. Fixed prices in this experiment. The haircut is a scenario. Read the comparison →

Three clocks matter.

The market prices the next cluster every day. The supplier books a sale when it delivers under the contract. The customer earns back the investment over the years it uses the equipment. Friday’s price supplies one observation. NVIDIA’s accounts supply a second. A return on every customer’s cluster would require a third.

That is why the series follows the money past the rack. It asks how much cash a customer supplies up front, what a second contract earns on paid-off equipment, and what happens to profit when expensive memory keeps an agent from having to do its work again. Those quantities can change while the share price is falling.

Published research

Read the series in order.

Browse all writing →

The value of a faster next token

Cerebras supplied an early example of what low-latency decode can buy. The saving compounds along the steps of a serial AI workflow.

What is the unit of AI demand?

John’s early-July thesis traced the economics of AI from a completed task through software, memory, compute, interconnect and power.

The bull market had a bear inside it.

The split between the broad index and semiconductor equities emerges.

The sell-off. The build-out.

The physical build-out carried on through a sharp fall in equities.

Bonfire Night in AI infrastructure

The semiconductor index fell 12.25% in a session. Five trading days took a five-year SOXL holding from $173 to $69 per $100 originally invested. Daily leverage and the path of returns explain how a holder could lose money while the unlevered index was up sharply.

What does the second customer pay for?

CoreWeave’s first contract can service the debt on a cluster. A later customer can rent the paid-off equipment. The economics of that second contract explain why gross capex alone misses a source of capital for the next build.

The market had its semiconductor downturn. Did the industry?

Two equity drawdowns looked familiar. Their operating evidence differed. Compare the semiconductor index, the wider market, and the sequential movement in industry sales before calling the price path a repeat of 2022.

$102 versus $14

Cisco and NVIDIA had each lost nearly 48% in the historical comparison. A dollar of trailing earnings cost about $102 at Cisco and under $14 at NVIDIA on the respective measurement dates. Matching drawdowns can conceal radically different starting economics.