Markets · 21 Nov 2026
$102 versus $14
Cisco and NVIDIA had each lost nearly 48% in the historical comparison. A dollar of trailing earnings cost about $102 at Cisco and under $14 at NVIDIA on the respective measurement dates. Matching drawdowns can conceal radically different starting economics.
$102 for a dollar of Cisco earnings. Under $14 for a dollar of NVIDIA earnings. Cisco was 47.9% off its high, NVIDIA 47.5% off its own. How many people invoking dot-com have actually done that arithmetic?
Cisco was making real money. Its latest quarterly profit had nearly doubled. On 19 December 2000, one share cost $41.75 and the previous four quarters had earned 41 cents a share. Even on Cisco’s own pro forma figures, you were still paying 71 times earnings.
On Friday, $125.53 bought a share of NVIDIA with $9.31 of earnings on the same trailing GAAP basis. Since the semiconductor index peaked in June, NVIDIA’s share price has fallen roughly 40% while those earnings have risen 43%.
Now hold Friday’s price and cut NVIDIA’s earnings in half. You get 27 times earnings. To reach Cisco’s valuation after its crash, NVIDIA’s annual earnings would have to fall from $9.31 to about $1.23 a share.
That’s an 87% haircut. If the dot-com comparison is about valuation, show me where the $8 a share goes.
Valuation experiment · NVIDIA / Cisco
How much profit has to disappear?
Hold NVIDIA at its 20 November close of $125.53. Cut its trailing earnings and see what a dollar of the remaining profit would cost.
Cisco on 19 Dec 2000: $41.75 ÷ $0.41 trailing diluted GAAP EPS = 101.8×. Fixed prices in this experiment. The haircut is a scenario. Read the comparison →